Blog
What helps when you and your partner keep fighting
It started with the dishwasher being loaded wrong, and forty minutes later it has arrived at "you're always like this". Nobody remembers the dishwasher anymore. Most couples know this route.
Fighting doesn't mean a relationship is going badly. Some couples hardly ever fight, others fight often and stay happy for decades. What the happy ones have in common is the way they fight.
Couples in the lab
Starting in the 1970s, psychologist John Gottman and his colleagues spent decades watching couples argue in a lab: on camera, hooked up to heart-rate monitors, their facial expressions coded second by second. The best-known result of that work is that some habits in an argument predict a breakup far better than others. Gottman calls them the "Four Horsemen".
The first is criticism, which means going after the person instead of the behavior. "You didn't load the dishwasher again" is a complaint; "you don't care about anything" is criticism. The second is contempt: sarcasm, eye-rolling, a mocking laugh. Gottman considers it the most destructive of the four. The third is defensiveness, answering every complaint with "well, you also". The fourth is stonewalling, shutting down and going silent in the middle of the fight.
No couple manages to avoid all four. The trouble starts when they become habits.
Some fights never get solved
Another of Gottman's observations is oddly comforting. By his count, about two thirds of the things couples argue about never get fully solved (Gottman Institute). One of you likes plans and the other likes winging it; one wants to see family every week and the other once a month. Those are differences in personality and lifestyle, and one argument isn't going to make them disappear.
The best you can do with topics like these is learn to talk about them for years without wounding each other. Knowing that takes some of the pressure off the "we have to settle this tonight" feeling, too.
How it starts is how it ends
An argument that starts harsh usually ends harsh. Gottman's answer is the "soft start-up": begin without blame, with your own feeling and a concrete request.
Instead of "you never help", try "I'm really worn out this week, could you make dinner tonight?" Longer, and a little stiff, we know. But the person who hears the second one is far more likely to say "sure".
Small repairs
Couples who fight well say hurtful things too. The difference is that they make small repair attempts in the middle of the fight, and those attempts get taken up. A joke, "wait, that came out wrong, let me start again", reaching for a hand, "okay, you're right about that part".
These attempts are often clumsy. A bad joke, half an apology. Whether they work depends on the other person noticing and catching them. When your partner tries to break the tension, smile once, even if the joke isn't actually funny.
Learn to take a break
At some point in an argument the body takes over. Your heart speeds up, your voice rises, and you stop being able to hear the other person. Gottman calls this "flooding". The Gottmans say that if your heart rate climbs above about 100 beats a minute during an argument, you're probably there (Gottman Institute), and carrying on from that point usually makes things worse.
Their suggestion is a break of at least twenty minutes, spent doing something that actually calms you down (a walk, a shower, music) instead of replaying the fight in your head. Say when you'll be back, by the next day at the latest; that's what separates a break from walking out. "I can't talk calmly right now, let's pick this up in half an hour" lands very differently from a slammed door.
After the fight
When it's over, talk about the fight itself. What set it off, who heard what wrong, what could go differently next time. That's easiest once you've both calmed down, ideally a day later.
The Tomurcuk question bank has a good one for this: "What do you still turn over in your head after our fights?" The answer sometimes teaches you more than the argument did. If you want to go deeper, there's a family question too: "How was anger lived out in your family, and how did that shape the way you argue?"
And if you want something lighter: "Which of us sends the first message after an argument?" You both already know the answer. It's still fun to say it out loud.